Pages

Saturday, April 5, 2008

The View from Saturday

Just a short post on the Listening Library version of E.L. Konigsburg's The View from Saturday...

I checked this out as an .mp3 download from our regional library cooperative. More than ten years after this Newbery winner debuted, this book is still a favorite. I was on a waiting list for the download.

This is the well-known story of a group of four diverse yet interconnected children, that competes in the Ephiphany Middle School's academic bowl under the direction of their paraplegic teacher, Mrs. Olinski. The parts of the story unfold and are told through the voices of each of the contestants and their teacher. This is a novel that lends itself perfectly to an audio version. This is a full-cast audio book, with a narrator voice as well.

With occasional segments from the narrator or the character of Mrs. Olinski, the story is told by the students - first Noah, then Nadia, then Ethan, and finally, Julian. In most instances, this makes it very easy to recall which character is telling the story at any particular time. The only exception to this rule is when the current narrator is relating the dialogue of another character. In these instances, as in real life, the narrator merely changes his or her voice to mimic that of the other character. Nadia's is the only voice that is incompatible with the story. I was unable to find the name of the actor who portrayed Nadia, but the voice sounds as if it belongs to a woman much too old to portray a young girl. This, however, was the only fault that I found in this otherwise stellar production.

Dizzy

Winter, Jonah. Dizzy. 2006. Ill. by Sean Qualls. New York: Scholastic.

Just in time for Jazz Appreciation Month, we received a new copy of a previously released picture book biography of jazz musician, Dizzy Gillespie. It is a J biography, targeted at older readers. Dizzy simultaneously chronicles the life of Dizzy Gillespie and the birth of the new form of jazz that Dizzy helped to invent, bebop. I have mixed feelings about the book.

The prose is wonderful and evokes the transition of jazz music from swing to bebop, switching cadences and syntaxes throughout the story.

"He was always mad.
You see, his dad
was always beating on HIM
and there was nothing he could do

but try to be tough
and try not to cry."

and then later

"For the boy with the horn
fueled with a FIRE
that burned with every whooping,
JAZZ was like a fire extinguisher. It was c o o o o o o o o l.

For the boy with the horn, stuck
inside a Podunk town
in the Deep South, where white folks put you down,
JAZZ was also like a ticket
on a train to better days.

So he boarded that train and moved up north
to a place they call Philly.
Right off the bat,
he got a job in a jazz band
and started acting silly."

Winter tells Dizzy's story beginning with a difficult childhood filled with rage, progressing to his musical awakening through the trumpet and the early days of jazz, and ending with his accomplishments as the confident and ebullient creator and master of the bebop jazz sound.

I may be of a minority opinion here, but I think that the illustrations fall short of capturing the scope of Dizzy Gillespie's life. Qualls definitely captures the mood of Dizzy's early life, with its poverty and rage. His acrylic and pencil illustrations with their muted blues, reds, and purples, also accurately capture the hot/cool jazz scene. What I find missing is the exuberance and joy of Dizzy's fun-loving spirit. In fact, only one illustration in the entire book features Dizzy with even the hint of a smile. Winter's biography depicts a Dizzy Gillespie that was known as much for his clowning around as for his revolutionary style of jazz. Qualls' artwork misses that note.

Animal Records

Carwardine, Mark. 2008. Natural History Museum: Animal Records. New York: Sterling.

This book is another in what seems to be a recent trend, nonfiction books meant for browsing. Although Animal Records is logically organized into chapters on mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, fishes, and invertebrates, it is still a collection of random facts on each species.
The book begins, of course, with aardvarks.

The aardvark entry is for "most burrows." The record? Sixty entrances. Whales, for example, have multiple entries, including "worst eyesight," "longest flippers," and "best-selling record!" "Male humpback whales are the only animals that can boast a top-selling record in the pop charts."

The book is primarily text, but interesting photographs of the fearsome, funny and unusual are plentiful. The index is helpful for finding entries quickly.

This may not be a useful book for school projects, but children should enjoy leafing through Animal Records for the photographs and interesting facts. Who knew that howler monkeys can be heard up to three miles away or that the Central and South American cockroach has a wingspan up to 7.25 inches?!

Beowulf: Monster Slayer

Storrie, Paul D. 2007. Beowulf: Monster Slayer. Ill. by Ron Randall. Minneapolis: Lerner.

Beowulf: Monster Slayer is a graphic novel in Graphic Universe's Myths and Legends series. Paul Storrie has written several of the Myths and Legends series titles; and both he and Ron Randall are accomplished comic book artists. The artwork is perfect for the genre, a sort of Prince Valiant meets Marvel Superheroes look. The dialogue, as well, fits the story admirably. The flavor of antiquity is retained, yet it is accessible to younger readers. The names of the story's characters are difficult, however, a helpful pronunciation key is included.

If the graphic novel is the modern answer to the assured continuation of our literary cultural heritage, then the genre is certainly a welcome addition. I do worry, however, that the readers of graphic novels, accustomed to dialogue-oriented stories, will be at a disadvantage when required to craft the complex sentences required for school papers, etc.

Young boys should love this book. Beowulf is a Children's Book Week Children's Choice nominee in the 5th and 6th grade category. http://bookweekonline.com/nominees.html

Friday, April 4, 2008

Free for All: Oddballs, Geeks, and Gangstas in the Public Library

Borchert, Don. 2007. Free for All: Oddballs, Geeks, and Gangstas in the Public Library. New York: Virgin Books.

As with my last foray into adult non-fiction (which is, incidentally, one of my favorite genres), I am returning this book unfinished. I feel guilty renewing it when so many others are waiting for this humorous look at public libraries.

Although the books is advertised as "mild-mannered librarian tells all!" it is actually the collected stories of a library assistant in a suburban L.A. public library. Free for All is definitely amusing, but since I'm living many of the scenarios on a day-to-day basis anyway, I'll pass on the rest of the book and get back to work serving children. I'm behind on my picture book reading!

Beneath the Waves - a review

As we read disturbing news accounts of dying manatees , environmental disasters caused by toxic waste, and ocean pollution on the scale of ...